Generation X May Boost Sagging Real-Estate Market

The boom may be over, but the long-term outlook for the industry is promising as younger consumers start to buy homes and trade up. But these buyers may press developers to consider new designs and different amenties than what homeowners have favored in the past.
By: Kristen Gerencher: The Wall Street Journal Online
The housing market may be in a slump, but the industry's long-term trends look promising as younger generations begin to buy and trade up. That was the consensus among a group of consultants, analysts and developers speaking at the recent annual meeting of the Urban Land Institute in Denver.

Rising affordability concerns in some home and rental markets remain a challenge, but the generations coming up behind the baby boomers are giving home builders a run for their money, experts said. With more immigration and people living alone, demographic shifts are pressing developers to reconsider what's worked in the past.

Generation X, typically defined as those born between 1965 and 1979, comprise a little more than half of the market for newly constructed homes, said James Chung, president of Reach Advisors, a Boston-based marketing strategy and research firm.

But that doesn't mean the homes that lured baby boomers, born between 1946 and 1964, are meeting the needs of the 30-somethings shopping now.

"Generation X is in the heart of their entry-level home-buying years and are just now entering their peak trade-up years," Chung said. "They haven't yet stolen the thunder of the boomers when it comes to trade-up homes. It's a big shift coming up for home builders and developers."

Partly because many Gen-Xers are buying into the market after the run-up in housing prices began about a decade ago, they tend not to be as moved by deluxe kitchens, huge square footage and "prestige addresses" as their older counterparts are, he said.

"It's the trade-off generation. It's no longer sort of the live-large mindset," Chung said. "They're living under different economic realities than their predecessors. They carry 70% more debt than the baby boomers did at that point in their lives because of the cost of housing.... Almost all of that is housing debt."

Many are forgoing master suites and separate wings for kids and adults and instead seeking smaller footprints with space designed for family usage rather than individual usage, Chung said.

The market has yet to catch up with their particular demands, he said. "What we're seeing is a fundamental mismatch between what these buyers are wanting and what the market is offering. They're settling for what's available vs. finding what they really want."

As for Generation Y, also know as the echo boomers who were born after 1980, it's premature to draw conclusions, Gadi Kaufmann, chief executive of Robert Charles Lesser and Co., a real estate advisory firm, said during a ULI panel discussion on what young consumers want.

"Gen Y is going to be in student housing and rentals for the next six years," he said. See how student housing has changed today.

More solo dwellers

Also affecting home builders and developers is the rise of nontraditional households, Kaufmann said.

The portion of people living without a spouse or roommate ballooned 23% since 1980, he said. Only 22% of households were made up of a single person living alone 26 years ago compared with 27% in 2005.

A 57% rise in single-parent households and a 26% decline in the percentage of married couples with kids - 23% last year compared with 31% in 1980 - has further changed the housing landscape, Kaufmann said.

There's also more migration from expensive cities to less costly areas, as well as people moving away from their hometowns, he said.

Southern states and those bordering pricey ones, such as Arizona and Nevada, are the beneficiaries of home buyers who can't afford or become disenchanted with higher-priced areas such as California and the Northeast, he said.

So-called second- and third-tier cities with populations of 300,000 to 1 million are attractive to the youth market and poised for growth, Kaufmann told the audience. "Some of the most exciting towns in America are those second-tier cities."

Young people also tend not to mind close living, he said. As more people live alone and wait longer to marry and start families, many in their 20s and 30s are drawn to compact apartment and condo units in urban areas where they can interact with their neighbors.

The growth of the Hispanic population also portends shifts, though what kind remains unclear, Chung said. Latinos currently have a homeownership rate in the high 40% range compared with about 72% for whites. "If they move up in homeownership at a faster rate, that's going to be very positive for the home market."

Love affair continues

Whether the housing market has hit a bottom or not remains controversial.

Last week, the U.S. Commerce Department reported that the nation's economy grew at a preliminary annual rate of 1.6% from July through September, its slowest pace since early 2003 due to cooling in the housing market.

In a survey done in October by Reach Advisors, 41% of 500 consumers looking to buy a house in the last 12 months or planning to look in the next year said their plans to move were affected by market conditions, compared with 27% of consumers who said so in July 2005, Chung told ULI attendees at a panel discussion on the risks and benefits of homeownership.

The portion anticipating a drop in home prices was 32% last month compared with 13% in July of last year, meaning that two-thirds still don't expect price drops, he said. What's more, 93% said owning a home remains a strong or acceptable long-term investment.

Though the housing market may be in the doldrums, Chung said he's confident Americans' love affair with homeownership will endure even after this recent extreme swing in demand. "From 2003 to 2005 it wasn't just a love affair with your primary home. It was a torrid affair with real estate. It was your home plus your home on the side."

Still, a balance of owners and renters is desirable because homeownership isn't for everyone, Ron Terwilliger, chief executive of Trammell Crow Residential, a builder and manager of multifamily housing based in Atlanta, said during the same ULI panel discussion.

"You're better off renting unless you're going to be in a home for at least five years because of the costs of getting in and out," he told attendees.

"The reason this cycle went up so high and flattened so quickly is more speculative buying than I've seen in my 35 years in the business," Terwilliger said. "It's unfortunate so many people bought intending to flip."

It will take time to regain equilibrium, he said. "There's a lot of pain going on in the investment community."